December 7, 2011 Gang Violence Persists in Struggling NYC Communities
New York, NY – For the last four years, Reggie Andrews had been in and out of jail and had been unable to spend his birthdays at home with friends and family. Andrews was turning 22 years old and was passing the day with his mother and his girlfriend. A home-cooked birthday dinner was being prepared for him in the upstairs apartment. Andrews, meanwhile, was fooling around on a bicycle down below when, according to the police, a group of young men approached him on the sidewalk. It was only just after four o’clock in the afternoon but suddenly shots rang out at the crossing of 111thstreet and Lenox Avenue. Reggie Andrews passed away on the pavement from a gunshot wound to his temple and two to his chest. It was November 12, 2011 and gang violence in Harlem had claimed another victim.
Many residents of the Harlem community refer to the violence as an “epidemic” due to the frequency with which it occurs. Nationally, the rate of gang membership has risen by 40 percent since January 2009, according to the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s National Gang Intelligence Center, which released its report earlier this October (FBI Report: Gang Membership Spikes). The FBI has linked the epidemic of gang activity nationwide to better reporting. But some experts argue with that conclusion, claiming that an exhausted economy is a much more likely culprit.
“When people don’t have jobs, when they’ve been displaced, the parent loses their job, they lose their apartment, they’ve been put into a shelter, they get moved from school to school – the stability is destroyed,” says Luis Osorio, director of the Cornerstone Program at the New York City Department of Youth and Community Development. “In order to maintain a sense of protectiveness and ‘famiglia,’ or family, [young people] join together with other young people that are in the same type of predicament or circumstances.”
The Harlem community, along with other parts of New York City, has lost countless youth to gang violence in just the past few years. There were 244 shootings in Harlem’s five police precincts between January 2010 and November 2011, according to Manhattan Supreme Court Judge Edward McLaughlin who cited these statistics at a sentencing on November 29th for five members of crack dealing gangs from Harlem. Of those 244 shootings, 277 people were shot and 34 of those victims died. More than half of those shootings that resulted in injuries were gang related and sadly, 32 of the 34 victims who died were 16 years old or younger (see Judge Lectures Harlem). Judge McLaughlin also noted that the estimate of gang-related violence is probably low due to a lack of witness cooperation with the police, according to news reports by The New York Post and DNAinfo.com. To view an excerpt of Judge McLaughlin’s speech, please click here.
Of the numerous causes of the success of gangs, the unwavering loyalty that members and their acquaintances will have to any given group or crew is a crucial one. In communities where gangs are prevalent there is a heightened sense of fear and witnesses, whether involved with a gang or not, are afraid to “snitch,” or tell the police or anyone else that is not supposed to know of the goings-on of local gangs. But gangs do not just instigate fear in outsiders. For insiders or gang members, they are a support system and a shield against bullying, theft, and physical harm. Andrews’s uncle Reverend Vernon Williams of Harlem, once a gang member himself, says that belonging to a group is simply a survival tactic for kids living in impoverished communities with high rates of crime.“We do ourselves a disservice when we say that kids coming from families with money are not in gangs,” he says. “You’re in a gang, you just don’t call it a gang. You just call it ‘hanging out with your friends.’ See, it’s given the evil connotation of a gang because of the poverty status.”
Reverend Williams agrees, however, that the problem with some of these groups is in their choice of behavior. While cliquing up is a human thing to do, using violence within and among those groups is not acceptable and is the result of a poor economy.
“The premise of a gang is ‘share the wealth,’” says Curtis Hoyte, a corrections officer at Rikers Island where he sees gang activity on a daily basis. “’If I have you have, if you have I have.’ Once one person is in there and they are doing what they have to do in order to get their quick money, the junior guy under him, he’s going to get something. But he’s obviously going to get something by having to do something else. So together, they’ll make money. “ He added: “It helps in a bad economy for a gang member, but it doesn’t help everyone else because everyone else loses.”
According to Reverend Williams, youth as young as 4 and 5 years old are being recruited into gangs. And this rise in gang activity and recruitment isn’t only occurring in New York City. With the economy weakened nationwide, all parts of the United States are experiencing gang growth. In The 2011 National Gang Threat Assessment – Emerging Trends the FBI claims that gang membership has increased most dramatically in the Northeast and Southeast regions.
The current situation, says Osorio, is quite serious. “We’re looking now at an escalation in housing developments and other areas of gang membership,” he says. One of the biggest factors is the lack of options for young people. “The devastating effect of the economy, the reduction in budget allocations for the summer youth employment program has increased membership in gangs because these young people would have been working. Now they’re on the street.”
Several anti-gun, anti-violence organizations and unofficial groups have formed in Harlem over the past few years to combat the rising trend of violence among the youth. Groups like Harlem Mothers Save located on Frederick Douglass Boulevard and Man Up In Harlem, a prayer group led by Reverend Al Taylor aimed at recruiting men in the community to speak out against violence, are just two groups made up of people like many others in the community – mothers and fathers, religious leaders, and even children – who are trying to eliminate gun violence and “beefing,” or confrontations between gangs, from their corner of New York City.
For Reggie Andrews, however, the anti-violence movement was not strong enough to save his life. At his funeral on November 22nd at the Metropolitan African Methodist Episcopalian church at the corner of Lenox Avenue and 135th St., adults and young people stepped up and spoke about the problem to the overflowing pews of family and friends. Reverend Williams was among those who spoke.
“If you really love Reggie,” he said to the many listeners, “Carry yourself accordingly. We are the only community that is killing itself.”
But of the many mourners that night, only a few of the youth were brave enough to stand up in front of their peers and condemn the violence themselves.
“Why don’t you put the guns down and pick up a book like I did?” a close friend of Reggie’s asked the audience. Meanwhile, angry whispers of planned retaliations and backlash against the suspected murderers could be heard circulating through the crowds of listeners.
The murder of Reggie Andrews remains unsolved, according to the police. Rumors in the neighborhood charge that the 28th Precinct has acquired a tape of the execution. The NYPD declined to comment about an ongoing investigation. It is also suspected by some members of the community, who wish to remain anonymous, that not only is the killer known, but also may have attended the funeral in person.
Regardless of the outcome of Reggie Andrews’s case, the cycle of violence in Harlem continues. Reverend Williams agrees that what needs to happen is not only an increase of available social programs in the community to occupy kids who are unable to get jobs, but without proper funding in the current recession, the community needs to first acknowledge the epidemic of violence.
“There has to be a whole lot of admittance as to why this is the way it is,” he says. “Parents, adults, leadership, elected officials, have to admit to their part in what is going on in society. Just like they had to admit to what was going on with slavery. Just like they had to admit to what was going on with civil rights. Once they admit to their part in it then the process is started for change to begin.”
Written by Katherine Crane, December 7, 2011